Overall, these are absolutely lovely skirts for an amazing price! I got both Emerald Dream and Witch's Garden, and while they do look slightly different (as disclosed), the fading isn't an issue to me at all. I love the way the skirts look and feel on me, and have already comfortably worn them both out and about as well as around the house. My order also included a freebie Dark Jungle bandana that I think is so cute, thank you so much for that!
My only real issue is sizing. I already owned a size A skirt I got secondhand that, while it technically fit, felt far too tight on me to be comfortable. This time I got size B, and while they’re much more comfortable, they’re borderline too big and I can only wear them quite low rise (especially if I don't layer anything underneath). For reference, I have a ~30” true waist - so I did buy size B knowing it’d likely be a bit oversized on me, but size A was just too tight to wear or buy more of.
This issue isn't a dealbreaker for me at this price, so I'm still very happy with this particular purchase, but I would likely hesitate to buy another skirt at full price when there’s no size that fits me quite right. If the skirt sizing ranges were ever to add more in-between options, then they’d be just about perfect!